making Sourdough Bread

There is nothing quite like having a fresh loaf of sourdough bread sitting on the kitchen counter for whoever happens to stop by. No special occasion required. Just good bread, a welcoming kitchen, and the joy of sharing what you’ve made.

Recipe:

Cindy’s Basic Sourdough Bread

1/2 cup active starter
2 1/2 cups warm water
2 teaspoons salt
5-6 cups flour (I usually use half whole wheat with half unbleached, but I recommend you start with white and work your way into whatever ratio of whole wheat you want)

Combine all together with 5 cups flour. Stir well and let sit for half an hour. Gently knead a few minutes (maybe five minutes), adding SOME of the remaining cup of flour as needed. Whether you use a mixer or you’re making by hand doesn’t matter. You do you. Cover your bowl and let sit overnight (at least 10 hours). I usually start my bread about 10:00 PM – before I go to bed.

In the morning, gently stretch-and-pull your dough again. Dough will be sticky. Don’t be tempted to add too much flour, just be gentle and add only as much flour as required to keep it from sticking to the counter. Let the dough rest about half an hour.

At this point, you can decide to make two smaller loaves or one bigger loaf.

TWO LOAVES:
I used to make two smaller ones, in greased bread pans or formed and placed on parchment lined cookie sheets.

Wet the counter top with water.
Turn dough onto the wet surface.
Wet hands and cut dough in half.
Let sit for a few minutes while you grease your pans, or prepare your parchment surface.

Take one piece at a time, and pat it onto your damp work surface. Shape into loaves and place into baking pans or onto parchment surface. Set aside in a warm place (covered with a wet cloth or plastic wrap) for at least 2 hours. You may have to re-moisten your cloth if it dries. Test the dough by gently pressing a fingerprint into it. If it doesn’t spring right back up, let it sit another 30 minutes.

Score the top of the loaf just before placing it in the hot oven.
See below for instructions on ‘scoring’.

Preheat the oven to 375F. When up to temperature, place your loaf pans or baking sheet in the middle of the oven. Bake for 25 minutes. The bread should be a golden brown and have a hollow sound when lightly tapped with your finger.

Remove from oven, turn out of pans onto a rack and allow to cool.
Don’t give in to the temptation of cutting into sourdough bread warm from the oven. The cooling period is important to the final baking process.
See below for more information on this stage.

ONE LOAF in a Dutch Oven

This will obviously be a bigger loaf, which I need since I started baking in a rather large dutch oven a few years ago. Everything in the two-loaf method is the same up till the part where you would otherwise divide the dough.

The method of baking will be a little different too.

One day my sister mentioned making a loaf of cranberry orange sourdough bread with rosemary.
I am very susceptible to suggestion, and it haunted me (in a good way).
I happened to have some fresh cranberries on hand , and some fresh rosemary growing in my front window. And whad’ya know? I even had an orange to zest.
The stars were in my favour, so I made one. It was faboulous!

Form your dough into a round loaf (or oval if your dutch oven is oblong). I make this amount into one large loaf, and put in my greased dutch oven.
Cover with the lid.
Let sit for 3 or 4 hours. Remember, this timing has a lot to do with the warmth of your kitchen. DON’T RUSH the SOURDOUGH. If my loaf has been sitting several hours and still has not risen very much (and is cool to the touch), maybe give it a little boost by turning the oven on to 300 degrees, and setting the pan on top of the stove to enjoy the warmth.
Don’t expect your sourdough to double in size like a regular loaf. It probably won’t. It’s NOT a regular loaf. Accept it for what it is. If you’re wondering if it is rising sufficiently, gently apply a little pressure with your finger. Is it soft and squishy? It should slowly return from a gently finger print. If yes, then its exactly how it should be.

When your loaf is ready to bake, preheat the oven to 450 degrees F. and SCORE your loaf – see below.
And yes, you read right – 450F. Not a typo.

Into a 450F oven with the lid on for 20 minutes.
REMOVE THE LID, reduce the heat to 400F, and continue to bake another 25 minutes. (total baking time 45 minutes – high heat)

Should be nicely browned, and sound hollow to the tap.
When done, remove from oven, and set on a rack or counter to cool.
Do NOT give into the temptation to slice into hot sourdough bread. The final cooking is happening while it is cooling.1 (see footnote below)

You’ll regret cutting into it too early. You’ll only do it once as you’ll likely find some uncooked dough in the centre.

https://backyardcityhomestead.com/2025/01/18/using-natural-yeast-sourdough/

Before baking:

  • You can spray your bread with water to make it a little more pliable in the oven during its final rise in the oven.
  • You can wash the top with olive oil for a beautiful sheen.
  • You can egg wash the top for a deep glossy finish.
    the cranberry orange loaf above has an egg wash on it – before I scored it
  • You can lightly dust with flour for a nice finish of a different kind.
  • You should probably try a different method each time you make a new loaf till you find the finish you prefer.
A banneton basket (also called a proofing basket) is structured basket that holds and shapes bread dough during its final rise before baking. It is typically made of woven rattan cane. I sprinkle rice flour liberally inside the basket before laying the dough in it, to ensure I can get it out easily. That’s what you see on the surface.

Tip:
Rice flour prevents dough from sticking to proofing basket. It is gluten free and resists absorbing moisture, acting as a non-stick barrier. Dusting the banneton with rice flour stops wet dough from gripping the wicker during long proofing.

Tip:
Don’t go out and buy rice flour just for this. Take a handful of rice and put it into the blender for a couple of minutes. If you don’t have a high powered blender, you can sift it and put the coarse parts back into the blender to blend again. Store remaining flour in a small glass jar.

What is scoring? and why should you score your sourdough bread?

How to score your sourdough bread? 

Scoring is cutting a slash into the surface of bread dough before baking. Bread dough expands rapidly when it is first placed in the oven, and scoring allows your bread to expand in a controlled way while baking, preventing cracking or bursting open. Scoring can also be used to create a decorative design.  If you do not score, the steam will often create its own place to escape, by bursting through on one side or the other.

Score to a depth of about 1/2 inch (or 1 centimeter). I know, that seems harsh, but get over it.
Use a very sharp blade like a razor blade. For a long time I used a knife but no matter how sharp your knife is, its not fine enough for the deep cut that you need. A razor blade is sharp and thin. Much better. Sometimes I’ve even snipped with scissors for an interesting look.

Make at least one confident deep stroke. Everything after that is decorative. Have fun experimenting.

click here to learn more about Sourdough, including how to make a starter and how to keep it healthy

More Fun Facts and Tips:

Scoring bread loaves was originally a way for families to identify their loaves when baking in a community oven. Home bakers would have ‘signature’ marks on their bread.

I used to bake my bread on a greased stone. If I cut my dough in half to make two smaller loaves, I’d bake on a greased cookie sheet. Now I prefer to use parchment paper (I LOVE parchment paper) and often reuse it several times. For the last few years, I’ve been baking my bread in a single large loaf in a Dutch oven, but I still occasionally use my baking stone. There IS NO right way. It’s just what works for you today.

Once you remove starter from your jar, feed it with equal amounts of flour and water. I usually default to 1/4 cup and 1/4 cup, but if you have a large amount, that will be too little. It’s easier to maintain a smaller amount of starter. How much is too much starter to maintain? I’d say anymore than two cups is too much unless you have an immediate need that you are building it for.

click here for some of my favourite ‘other’ recipes using Natural yeast

what to bake it on:
I used to bake my bread on a greased stone. If I cut my dough in half to make two smaller loaves, I’d bake on a greased cookie sheet. Now I prefer to use parchment paper (I LOVE parchment paper) and often reuse it several times. For the last few years, I’ve been baking my bread in a single large loaf in a Dutch oven, but I still occasionally use my baking stone. There IS NO right way. It’s just what works for you today.

keeping your starter happy:
Once you remove starter from your jar, feed it with equal amounts of flour and water. I usually default to 1/4 cup and 1/4 cup, but if you have a large amount, that will be too little. It’s easier to maintain a smaller amount of starter. How much is too much starter to maintain? I’d say anymore than two cups is too much unless you have an immediate need that you are building it for.

what people call “DISCARD” and what to do with it

As you continue to nurture your natural yeast starter, you should ideally be making enough bread to keep your starter to the amount you need to bake plus enough left over to continue growing more for next time. You may fall behind, and not bake bread as frequently from time to time, leading to an increased amount of healthy starter. If it isn’t being fed enough for its increasing appetite, your starter will get week and cease to actively reproduce. If you ARE continuing to keep it strong and healthy by feeding it, you’ll soon find yourself in a surplus situation – more than you need.

You have two options:

1. dispose of the excess: in your compost, in your garbage, or diluted with water and rinsed down the sink.2 This is why its called ‘discard’.

Personally I HATE wasting anything of value. And starter has value to me.
I never throw it away. I use the second option.

2. make something other than bread with it
Below are a few of my favourite recipes for crepes and waffles, but you can also make muffins, pancakes, quick-breads and many other tasty things. Keep your eyes open for good recipes.

click here for some of my favourite ‘other’ recipes using Natural yeast

Kitchen Tools that come in handy

Large mixing bowl

dough scraper
One of my most indispensable utensils, I hardly go a day without using it. To cut dough, pizza, squares, cake, grilled cheese sandwiches, . . . . To scrape counter tops for easy clean up.

Dutch oven or baking stone
I like that each of these are heavy, which helps them retain heat longer. I use the dutch over as a ‘bread box’ to store the bread in till I make another loaf.

Baking Stone
I love my baking stone, and can hardly remember a time when I didn’t use it. I found that it paid to get a good one. They work by absorbing and retaining heat, which is then distributed into the food, resulting in a crispy bottom with the top and sides cooked by radiant heat. 

For breads, baking stones provide “oven spring” (the final rising that happens in the oven), quickly cooking and crisping the bottom while simultaneously causing the yeast to begin a feeding frenzy that releases carbon dioxide and steam into the dough for a lighter and airier crust.

parchment paper to link the baking surface for no stick and easy clean up

food safe glass jars
for storing your starter in. I generally use pint sized jars, but occasionally if I have to make more starter to share or prepare extra recipes, I’ll temporarily use a quart jar till I can bring my starter back down to a more sustainable size.

Danish Dough Whisk
This is a new tool to me. A friend gave it to me as a birthday gift last year and I hung it with my other tools and liked the look at it. It took me over a year to finally use it though. I was surprised at how well it assimilated all my dry ingredients, and equally surprised at how thoroughly the liquids were incorporated, and how gently it worked. Game changer from now on for muffin batter. Give it a try.

I really hope you’ll give sourdough a try. It takes some adjusting to your thinking if you’re accustomed to making ordinary bread, but once you’ve made that adjustment so that your expectations are reasonable, you’ll love the lifestyle it brings with it.

Please let me know your thoughts, and if you have any favourite recipes – share them in the comments. I love trying out new recipes.

Warmly,

Cindy Suelzle

Using natural yeast / sourdough starter for things other than bread

Your sourdough starter is capable of so much more than making bread! There is a whole world of delicious baking beyond the traditional loaf. From pancakes, waffles and biscuits, to muffins, crepes, crackers, pizza dough, cinnamon rolls and even cookies, sourdough can find its way into all sorts of wonderful recipes.

Don’t limit yourself to bread. Put that starter to work and discover just how versatile it can be! Here are some of my favourite recipes.

click here to find out more about natural yeast, and how to care for it

Natural Yeast Crepes

adapted from a recipe by Melissa Richardson in “The Art of Baking with Natural Yeast”
this amount is good for three people

1 cup starter
2 Tablespoons butter
1/4 cup sugar or maple syrup
1/2 teaspoon salt
4 eggs
1/2 cup milk OR better yet, homemade kefir or whey
1/2 cup flour
Blend all ingredients together in blender. So easy.
Pour 1/4 cup onto hot very lightly greased griddle, spread around with the back of a spoon, or by tilting the pan in a circular movement to spread the batter thinly across the surface.
When bubbles have stopped forming in the batter and the crepe is no longer shiny on top, flip it over for about half the time it took to cook the first side.
Remove from pan and lay on a plate, covered with a clean dry cloth.

Continue cooking in 1/4 cup increments till done. Do not add anything more to grease the surface of the griddle.

  • If the batter doesn’t spread easily or evenly, add a little more milk and puree again.

Serve with fresh berries, your favourite fruit spread, syrup, homemade jam or marmalade, or dusted lightly with icing sugar. Crepes are also terrific when served with savoury fillings or toppings like chopped chicken salad.

Waffles – let me just give praise for the humble versatile waffle!
Waffles can be anything you want them to be: a breakfast bread or dessert – (my daughter bakes certain of her cookies in a waffle maker), for dinner as cornbread with chili soup (your favourite cornbread recipe spooned onto a waffle iron), or for dinner as the base for serving pulled pork or chicken n waffles.

Crispy Oatmeal Waffles

(adapted from a recipe by Melissa Richardson in “The Art of Baking with Natural Yeast”
– this amount is good for four people –
4 eggs
1 cup milk
1 Tablespoon oil
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 cup starter
1/2 cup flour
3 Tablespoons sugar
1 cup regular rolled oats
Combine everything except the oats into a blender and puree till light and fluffy.
Pour into mixing bowl and gently fold in oats with a spatula.

* If you don’t have a blender, beat eggs first, then add everything except oats to egg mixture, whisking to thoroughly incorporate. Add oats at last of all, gently folding in.
Allow to rest for about 10-15 minutes to moisten and soften oats.

Heat waffle iron, lightly greasing while it’s warming up. Pour approximately 1/3 – 1/2 cup measurements into the hot waffle iron and cook as you normally would. About 4 minutes. Don’t over cook them.

Serve with homemade syrup or berry sauce. I like to serve with fresh apple sauce with a drizzle of maple syrup.

Airy, Light, Natural Yeast Waffles

– this amount is good for three people
3 eggs
1/2 cup starter
1/2 cup flour
1/2 cup milk
1 T oil
1/4 t salt
1 T brown sugar
Combine everything together in a blender.
If you don’t have a blender, beat eggs first, then add everything to egg mixture and gently whisk to thoroughly incorporate.

Pour into HOT waffle iron and cook 4 minutes.

Sourdough Tortillas

– this is a surprisingly easy tortilla using the basic bread ingredients of flour and water with one addition
1 cup active starter
1 cup water
1/4 cup melted butter
3 cups unbleached flour
little bit of oil for grilling

Whisk water, starter and butter together. Add flour and mix to combine.
Knead a little to smooth out dough – which may be quite sticky.
Cover and let sit 3 or 4 hours depending on how cool your kitchen is, could be longer.
*Remember NEVER rush the sourdough.
Check a few times during the rising time to see how its going. Set in warm area if your kitchen is quite cool.
When your dough is nice and soft – check by gently poking with your finger – a soft nicely risen dough bounces back, dump out onto counter top. Gently knead by stretching and pulling the dough for a few minutes till surface is smooth and you can see the gluten is stretching. If you feel you need a little more flour – add sparingly.
Cover lightly and let sit another 1/2 hour or so.
Cut dough into 16 pieces.
Roll each piece into a round thinly.

Heat skillet over high heat. Spread a light skiff of oil onto skillet and place raw tortilla onto it. Watch carefully, air pockets will form and may even rise with one big air bubble. Wonderful. I love when that happens. Gently flip over with spatula or tongs. The other side will be quick. Place onto plate and cook another. Repeat till they’re all done.

click here to read more about using natural yeast and making sourdough bread

Nothing says “Welcome home Mom! I missed you!” like a sourdough starter

I left eight days before. A trip with my sister.

It was the end of March and that time of year, somebody always gets left with the responsibility of taking care of the garden seedlings, making sure they get enough water but not too much, and just enough light.

And then there is the sourdough I had three starters on the go (don’t ask me why three). I fed them before I left, but I forgot to tell Dan they needed to be put in the fridge that morning. Eight days ago. So I was a little worried when I saw them still sitting on the counter.

Oh the bubbles!
That’s how you know things are right in the world.

Totally my fault; with all the hullabaloo of getting out on time I neglected to mention that they should go in the fridge, and he’s used to seeing assorted fermenting ‘things’ on the counter.

They were looking a might peaked when I got home, so I started a batch of bread for dinner tomorrow. Still quite a bit of starter left, so I also made some blueberry sourdough muffins which I intended to bake in the morning for Easter breakfast.

The batter was surprisingly robust for the starter being neglected so long. Nice and bubbly. I put the batter in the fridge overnight. 😁

Sourdough Blueberry Muffins

start with:
1/2 cup starter
1 cup plain yogurt or plain kefir
1/2 tsp salt
1/4 cup sugar
2 cups unbleached flour

Mix the starter and yogurt or kefir with whisk. Add salt, sugar and flour and stir to fully moisten. This will be very thick.
Cover the bowl with a lid or plastic wrap and set aside over night (or 8-12 hours).

3/4 cup soft butter
1/2 cup sugar
3 eggs
1 tsp vanilla
2 cups freeze dried blueberries (or frozen)


When muffin batter has risen significantly, stir slightly down.
In separate bowl cream butter with sugar.
Beat in eggs and vanilla.

Pour the egg mixture into the sourdough mixture and stir gently till all incorporated.
Add 2 cups freeze dried blueberries and fold in.

Allow to sit half an hour.
Spoon into muffin lined tins, filling each nearly to the top.

* Sprinkle a little sugar over top each muffin.

Bake at 350F for 20. Test with your finger before assuming they’re done. If the muffin is too soft, give it another 2 or 3 minutes.

Enjoy.

click here to find out more about natural yeast, and how to care for it

Warmly,

Cindy Suelzle